top of page

Why Is It So Hard to Start Again?

Nov 8
5 min read

Unpack guilt, shame, perfectionism, comparison with our past selves, and the psychology behind what we call self-sabotage.


Key takeaway: A lapse is something that happened, not a verdict on who you are.


When good habits feel like a long list of "to-dos" in an day already overextended with a long to-do list
When good habits feel like a long list of "to-dos" in an day already overextended with a long to-do list

You know what to do. You remember how good that good habit felt.

Yet the longer you've been away, the harder it can become to walk back through the door. WHY!?


There are several reasons.


Reason #1: The Actual Size of the Action

A small interruption vs. a confession


"I haven't been to yoga in a few days," is simply a small interruption. "I haven't been to yoga in four months" on the other hand, feels more like a confession.

And a confession is loaded with rationale and emotion. Let’s start with the rationale.

I’m out of shape. I’m behind. Everyone else has kept going and I’ll be out of the loop. I'll have to start from scratch.


Wait a minute – how did that single action —attending a class—turn into an entire project involving fitness, discipline, motivation, and personal redemption?

No wonder it’s so hard to get back into a good healthy habit!


The actual first step is small; the story we've built around it is enormous.


You don't have to make up for every missed class. You don't have to recover your former flexibility in a week. You don't have to prove anything to anyone. Period. Take everyone else out of your head and show up (in any situation – not just your yoga class) however you are in this moment.


Reason #2: The Power of Shame

Missing a habit is a fact, not a a statement about your value


"I missed class" becomes "I'm so inconsistent."

"I haven't exercised" becomes "I'm lazy."

“I’ve been busy” becomes “I’m not committed to what matters.”

"I said I'd do X, Y, Z every morning, and I didn't" becomes "I never follow through on anything."


When a behavior becomes a judgment about our character, returning to it can feel emotionally uncomfortable because we aren't just facing the effort of doing something; we're facing the feelings associated with having stopped.


Research on habit disruption highlights how this can create a damaging cycle. In their 2024 review in Social and Personality Psychology Compass, Benjamin Gardner and colleagues discuss how a lapse can trigger negative thoughts and emotions that undermine subsequent efforts to change. When we interpret a slip as proof of failure, we may be more likely to abandon the effort altogether.


It’s just information – it’s not a verdict.


Simply ask:

·       What changed in my life?

·       What made this habit difficult to maintain?

·       Was my original plan realistic?

·       What would make returning easier now?

These questions help you identify the actions that might actually work to help you take that first step.


Self-compassion isn't the same as letting yourself off the hook; t means approaching yourself in a way that makes constructive change possible.


Reason #3: Internal UN-clarity

The confusion between long-term and immediate


The term self-sabotage can be misleading if it makes us imagine that we're deliberately trying to ruin our own lives. Certainly, we don’t intend to make things more difficult than they need to be! It’s really a conflict between what we want in the long term and what we're trying to manage in the short term.


It’s that stuff in the immediate moments that takes so much effort and energy to manage, and it becomes mental clutter so that we can’t see the long-term goals. Those things that are most important to us (i.e., our physical, mental and emotional health) are less tangible than a deadline imposed by a boss, a set date for something such as a birthday, holiday, graduation, etc., or the urgency of an upcoming decision.


To return to a healthy habit often triggers internal questions rooted in doubt:

"What if I fail again?"

"What if I discover that I’m not as capable as expect to be?"

"What if I DO succeed and then have to maintain that success?"

"What if taking care of myself means setting boundaries with other people?"


These aren't conscious questions; they are the doubts that show up as procrastination, avoidance, or a sudden loss of enthusiasm just when we're about to begin.


Asking the questions though, will help clarify what’s going on that keeps you from returning to that healthy habit.


Wondering what to do next. What is the first step to returning to a healthy habit?
Wondering what to do next. What is the first step to returning to a healthy habit?

ONE

Shift into the healthy habit:

  • Remember why you started in the first place

  • Forget the “should” and look at evidence from you own personal experience. How did that healthy habit improve your life originally? Did it give you more energy? More confidence? More physical comfort? More mental peace?


TWO

Start smaller than you think you should

Small actions may seem unimpressive compared with the transformation you're hoping for. But they reduce the friction involved in beginning, and they give you an opportunity to repeat the behavior.


In their 2010 study, Lally and colleagues found that habit automaticity developed gradually through repetition in a consistent context, with considerable differences between individuals. Their findings support a simple principle: don't expect an established routine to appear overnight.


You are not trying to accomplish everything in your first week back. You are rebuilding a relationship with a behavior you want in your life.


THREE

Make the habit easier to do

Want to practice yoga? Put your mat where you can see it. Choose your class in advance. Put it on your calendar.


Want to walk more? Keep comfortable shoes by the door and identify a route you enjoy.


Adriaanse and colleagues' 2011 experiments suggest that planning an alternative response in advance can help interrupt habitual behavior.


Try this formula:


Mental preparation helps make positive habits easier to shift into.
Mental preparation helps make positive habits easier to shift into.

FOUR

Stop treating a missed day as a failed plan.


You will miss a class sometimes. You will sleep through an alarm. You will have difficult weeks. You will stop a routine again.

That doesn't mean though, that your plan has failed. It means you need a way to return.

Try making a Return Plan now:


You don't need a perfect streak. You just need a workable way back.



FIVE

Put the reward in the front of your mind


  • Notice how your body feels after each time doing the new habit. Notice it and articulate that explicitly:

  • Tell a friend

  • Write it down

  • Speak it out loud

  • Keep a note in your calendar


SIX

Support Matters


Tell a friend your intention, then follow up with a text saying that you did the thing.

Invite a friend to join you.

Do the thing in community rather than on your own (i.e., practice yoga at a set time – a class on a schedule instead of finding a video on YouTube and doing it whenever you feel like it).


The most effective thing you can do for yourself as you find your way back to the healthy habit is to be in an environment that makes the next good choice easier.

 

Zokawa: The Center of Happiness community welcomes you no matter when and no matter what.
Zokawa: The Center of Happiness community welcomes you no matter when and no matter what.

Research references

1. Lally, P., van Jaarsveld, C. H. M., Potts, H. W. W., & Wardle, J. (2010). “How are habits formed: Modelling habit formation in the real world.” European Journal of Social Psychology, 40(6), 998–1009.

2. Moshontz, H., et al. (2021). “Resisting, Recognizing, and Returning: A Three-Component Model and Review of Persistence in Episodic Goals.” Social and Personality Psychology Compass.

3. Gardner, B. (2024). “What is habit and how can it be used to change real-world behaviour? Narrowing the theory–reality gap.” Social and Personality Psychology Compass.

4. Adriaanse, M. A., Gollwitzer, P. M., De Ridder, D. T. D., de Wit, J. B. F., & Kroese, F. M. (2011). “Breaking Habits With Implementation Intentions: A Test of Underlying Processes.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 37(4).

5. Galla, B. M., & Duckworth, A. L. (2015). “More Than Resisting Temptation: Beneficial Habits Mediate the Relationship Between Self-Control and Positive Life Outcomes.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 109(3), 508–525.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page